BUILD Blog


Phoenix Architecture: Part Two
June 25, 2008, 11:53 am
Filed under: Architecture, Rural Architecture, The Modern List, Travel

Part two of our Phoenix series focuses on Frank Lloyd Wright and a couple of his most prominent works in the area. Up in the rainy northwest Uncle Frank isn’t as influential as his international popularity might suggest. The northwest is host to only a few residential projects by Wright – these projects are tucked away, privately held and rarely, if ever, open for tours. Wright’s most notable architectures were born from very different regions and climates making him a distant and elusive character to some of us soggy Seattleites. With this said, I was amazed at the impact both projects had on how we (BUILD llc) think about and do architecture. Both works have elements that are significant and applicable to a small, modern design-build practice. As part of our “on-location” blogs we’ll dive into some photo details on each project.


[photo by BUILD llc]

Taliesin West
Wright’s commonly repeated phrase “you learn by doing” typifies the philosophy of Taliesin West. Gradually constructed over years by many students the campus is a laboratory for designing and building. What is most refreshing about Taliesin West is the lack of precision. We so commonly associate Wright’s work with excessively expensive, finely crafted, precious objects, that the improvised and in some cases crude forms are refreshing.


[photos by BUILD llc]

The triangle is king at Taliesin West, three point geometries can be found in most of the built-form. The shape of the triangle, it was explained, symbolizes the sharp inhospitable surrounding environment.

[photo by BUILD llc]

It is said the Wright did not like the look of exposed light bulbs. Naked bulbs are abundant at Taliesin West, however they are always intentionally located and seem to integrate with the built-form. Even though this technique requires a bit more labor, the exposed bulb solution is as cost effective as lighting design gets.

[photo by BUILD llc]

The most pleasing aspect of Taliesin West involves the balance between massive stone and concrete walls unified with the delicate wood, steel and glass frameworks. The combination is sensible; the concrete and stone walls are so massive, so dominating that the wood/steel frameworks don’t necessarily need to align with them. A margin of error is inherently built into the construction and a level of sloppiness goes unnoticed.


[photos by BUILD llc]

Taliesin West was seen as a work in progress – glass walls could be turned opaque, entrances could be relocated, bays could be added. The concept of organic architecture, like nature, could evolve and adapt to the environment around it. There is an experimental and transitory nature about Taliesin West that would be nice to see in more modern built work.


[photos by BUILD llc]

While the bathroom in Wright’s quarters has been updated several times, its current state is quite pleasing. The Kohler fixtures obviously weren’t part of the original design however the ribbed aluminum siding was added by Wright. The contrast of materials, clean geometries and efficiency of the space make you feel like you just stepped into a bathroom at a high-end boutique hotel in New York.

[photo by BUILD llc]

The Biltmore Hotel
At the other end of the spectrum, the Biltmore exemplifies permanence, refinement and precision. The architect of record for the project is Albert Chase McArthur, a former apprentice of Wright’s. He and Wright, the consulting architect on the project, designed the 39 acre site which remains a hotel and resort today. While the project seems exclusive a simple room can be rented for around $170 – surprisingly inexpensive given the quality, service and amenities of the establishment. As an architect it’s a bit of paradise – you can roam anywhere you like on the grounds and no one seems to care how many photos you take.

[photo by BUILD llc]

Wright’s well known quote “Take care of the luxuries first, the necessities will follow” seems fitting of the Biltmore. Indulgence can be found everywhere from the overall planning down to the details. Although the extravagance of the architecture can be overwhelming, even discouraging given the challenges of doing architecture in today’s world, you can’t help but appreciate the discipline of the built-form. While there is a massive volume of usonian blocks used on the project the blocks are used judiciously and cleverly in harmony with simple plane faced concrete blocks.


[photos by BUILD llc]

The design of reproducible, textured concrete blocks lets nature do the work as the shadows throughout the day constantly change the appearance surfaces.


[photos by BUILD llc]

Light blocks are integrated into the block geometry to illuminate the spaces at night. The block lights have a glowing effect, rather than a pointed light effect, more conducive of a place for relaxation.


[photos by BUILD llc]

While the structures and nature appear to grow and evolve with one another, the army of gardeners each morning reminds us that this harmony between built-form and nature is very much contrived here.


[photos by BUILD llc]



Modern Tour: Arizona + New Mexico

BUILD is heading to the south-west and we need your advice. We’ve put together a rough agenda of modern gems not to be missed but this is a part of the globe we’re not particularly familiar with and we could use some pointers. While the natural wonders in this region are spectacular this tour is all about art and architecture. Here’s what we’ve come up with so far, let us know what we need to get on the agenda.

Walter De Maria Lighting Field in Quemado New Mexico
[Photo by Dia Art Foundation]
[Photo courtesy of Dia Art Foundation]

Taliesin West in Scottsdale Arizona by Frank Lloyd Wright

[Photo courtesy of Taliesin West]

Phoenix Central Library in Phoenix Arizona by Will Bruder
1221 N Central Ave, Phoenix, AZ


[Photos by Timothy Swope]

Scottsdale Museum of Contemporary Art in Arizona by Will Bruder
7374 East 2nd Str

Hotel Valley Ho in Scottsdale Arizona, 6850 E. Main Str

National Radio Astronomy Observatory in Socorro New Mexico

Roden Crater in Flagstaff Arizona

Holy Cross Chapel at 780 Chapel Rd Sedona Arizona

Mii Amo Spa & Enchantment Resort in Sedona Arizona by Gluckman Maynar Architects

Meinel Optical Science Research Building by Richärd + Bauer Architecture
University of Arizona Campus in Tuscon Arizona

Stevie Eller Dance Theatre by Gould Evans Associates
University of Arizona Campus in Tuscon Arizona

Citizens Bank of Clovis in New Mexico

Arizona Biltmore in Phoenix Arizona by Frank Lloyd Wright, 1929

First Christian Church Bell Tower in Phoenix Arizona by Frank Lloyd Wright

There is quite a bit of work by architect Rick Joy that we greatly admire however the residences seem rather secluded and private – so we’re not planning on any fly-bys. Let us know if you know of any public work by Rick Joy, restaurants, bars…

Thanks to 2modern for their previous post on “Modern Phoenix” which helped us out with our research.



Architecture and Discipline

It happens quite often, we’re at a cocktail party, a gathering, someone asks us what we do, we say we’re architects… and the response usually applauds the creative process. “It must be nice to do something so creative for a living” or “you must be a very creative person” or “I always wanted to do something creative like architecture”. Which is great, we’re honored to be thought of as creative and enamored that people are paying attention to the architecture around them.

The irony, however, is that good architecture is less about creativity and more about discipline. Granted, schematic design requires a great amount of creativity and the design and construction process necessitates creative problem solving. But in our opinion it is discipline in architecture that generates masterful, functional, inspiring architecture. Knowing what not to do. Just because there is a good view doesn’t mean that you fill the room with windows everywhere.

It is this restraint in design that is so important to a finished work. The projects that exercise discipline seem to forego fashion and grasp at a clarity of form and a timeless architecture. Such work creates a set of guiding principles and maintains an architectural thesis just as adamantly as it keeps the heat in and the rain out.

In doing our research on this theme we became quickly disenchanted with gathering the usual suspects – Mies, Breuer, Corbu, Kahn, Ando, etc. All masters of this architectural obedience but most of you are already very familiar with their work. They are extremely well documented and your bookshelves are most likely lined with their monographs. So we thought it might be a better use of our caffeine fueled research, and more enjoyable for us, to cover some of the lesser known architects - also well versed in an architecture of discipline.

Casa Pellico in Puebla, Mexico by Gerardo Balcazar, 2003

[Photos from the book Arquine + RM, Arquitectura Mexicana 2001-2004]

H Loft in Manhattan by Kar-Hwa Ho, 2002


[Photos by Bjorg Photography from the book New York Minimalism by Aurora Cuito]

Innfeld House in Schwarzenberger, Austria by Dietrich + Untertrifaller Architekten, 1999

[Photos from the book Country Modern by Aurora Cuito]

Pawson Residence in London by John Pawson, 1999



[Photos by Christoph Kicherer from the book Living and Eating by John Pawson and Annie Bell]

Miramar House in Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal by Eduardo Souto de Moura, 1991

[Photos by Luis Ferreira Alves from the book Ten Houses by Oscar Riera Ojeda]

Rosen House (Case Study House #11) in Los Angeles by Craig Ellwood, 1962

Kjaerholm near Copenhagen Denmark by Poul Kjaerholm, 1962


[Photos by Per Nagel & Vibe Udsen from the book Scandinavian Modern Houses by Faber & Udsen]

Gunnlogsson Residence in Oresund, Denmark by Halldor Gunnlogsson, 1958


[Photos by Nagel & Udsen from the book Scandinavian Modern Houses by Faber & Udsen]

Villa Bianca in Seveso, Italy by Giuseppe Terragni, 1937

Let us know who’s on your list of lesser known, well disciplined, residential architects…



A new visual language for architecture

Each generation of architects seems to establish their own language of visual presentation. The crisp graphite lines and dramatic perspective drawings characterize the 50’s and 60’s. Bold water colors and loose geometries are reminiscent of the 70’s, the occasional clip-art guy with mustache and sports jacket thrown in for good measure. While these examples seem humorous and dated today they were the Hotty McHottersons of the time. Today’s blog entry is in pursuit of the current zeitgeist of visual language. You know us well enough by now to know that we’re not going to exhibit high-end presentations from the starchitects and mega-shops out there. We don’t think that it will be these enterprises that set the curve with their armies of lowly paid interns and exclusive modeling software. If you ask us, it will be the small shops in the trenches of practice and academia that will be most infectious with the new language because they have the same common denominators as the majority of us in terms of resources, staff & software; it’s just that they’re using these resources more intelligently and doing more with them. We’ve selected several groups that we’ve come across over the years and, in our opinion, they are forming the new visual protocol. The new language seems to be moving away from fashion, is taking on more analysis and is communicating more technical data. More important than the sexy imagery, it is the thinking behind these presentations that is generating the new language. Let us know who’s setting the curve for you…

KBAS Studio
Portland Thru-House

Cutting sections within a perspective drawing is a very intelligent use of modeling programs. The section cut is clearly indicated with the orange highlight and the interiors elevations have definition. This single image is communicating information traditionally accomplished with a perspective, a section cut and interior elevations.

The image shows the efficiency of building a model once and getting multiple levels of information and imagery by turning on and off layers.  Subtle shadows give the simple models a level of sophistication.


Palisades Glacier Mountain Hut




The drawing includes a dynamic element and explains the circulation.


John Szot
Coney Island Pavilion



Using actual photos of graffiti as “decals” within the modeling program, the image achieves a gritty, urban feel. The series takes into account an aspect of urban weathering. Subtle lighting and ordinary weather conditions create a powerful presentation. The abstract people give a sense of scale and population without detracting from the rendering.


Saddle Creek


Living Smart Project

The imagery breaks the house apart like a piece of machinery.


Levin Residence

Tangible representations are created by embedding photographs into the model.
They have an excellent collection of graffiti and tags on their website.


SHoP
Portland Ariel Tram

The element of scale exists with the figures but the transparent shadow technique keeps the focus off the figures and on the architecture.


Lorcan O’Herlihy
Calarts Dormitory

The landscaping is suggested but does not overwhelm the image. Site circulation and dynamics are added as a layer to the presentation.


Paulith

Subtlety of light and shadow give a tangible impression of how the space may feel.


Asymptote
166 Perry Street

Using digital software to do what it does best - figuring out all of the intricacies and reflections of varying environmental conditions.


Penang Global City Center



The display and comprehension of extremely complex geometries.


Jones Partners
Yucca Valley House

The use of extreme detail (even the lights have been precisely modeled) allows the rendering to serve as a form of quality control and troubleshooting for the finished work.


Preston Scott Cohen
Lightfall

Communicating the process of design and allowing an observer (or more importantly a client) to understand the geometrical evolution of a design.


Public Arcade

Presenting, comparing and contrasting variations/mutations of form.


Wu House

Clarifying and simplifying the complexities of hybrid geometries.


Neil M. Denari
Massey House

Merging renderings with construction documents the renderings start to become technical data which could be used as reference in the field.



The rigor of process: Lorcan O’Herlihy
April 14, 2008, 10:51 pm
Filed under: Architecture, Rural Architecture, Urban Architecture

We’ve wanted to do a post on the work of Lorcan O’Herlihy for quite some time now. The difficulty was in trying to define the work and come up with an intelligent, blog-friendly theme to focus on. There is certainly the filtration of light in many of the projects, breathtaking stairways are incorporated into others, some projects were derived from an exploration of eloquent, clean diagrams, and others still develop rich, tangible line-weight drawings reminiscent of ink on mylar hand drawings. The finished products are masterful and the evidence of the design process is inspiring and infectious. We came to the conclusion that it is the consistency of the entire process that makes the work of Lorcan O’Herlihy so significant. From diagram to line drawing to model/rendering to built-form; each step of the way appears thorough and masterful. In a nut-shell, these guys are just damn good architects. Given the constant pressure of time and budget in the industry, these guys seem to keep the discipline of process in the formula. For this weeks entry we’ve chosen several projects of theirs that display the rigor of process.

CalArts dormitory at the California Institute of the Arts in Valencia CA, in process

Jai House in Calabasas CA, 2004

Paulith Headquarters CA, 2004

12 Houses in Mt. Washington CA, in process


Formosa 1140 in Los Angeles CA, 2008

Sherman Residence in Mill Valley CA, 2005

Vertical House in Venice CA, 2004

Willoughby Avenue Lofts in Los Angeles CA, in process


W.A. Lofts in Los Angeles CA, in process