BUILD Blog


AIA Seattle: 2008 Honor Award Winners for Washington Architecture

2008-honor-awards-for-washington-architecture

AIA Seattle hosted the 2008 Honor Awards for Washington Architecture on Monday, November 3rd in Seattle. This years theme was “Perform Transform -recognizing the challenges and opportunities inherent in our work as this new century unfolds.  Our work must perform technically, aesthetically and humanistically.  Our practice must transform itself in response.”  BUILD was in attendance and we took thorough notes for those of you who couldn’t make it. The jury was as follows:

Moderator: Susan Szenasy (SS), Editor in Chief Metropolis Magazine, New York, NY
Patricia Patkau (PP), of Patkau Architects, Vancouver, B.C.
Nader Tehrani (NT), of Office dA, Boston, MA
David Baker (DB), of David Baker + Partners, San Francisco, CA

The ceremony started off with an interpretive dance which was a new twist – although beautifully done, do we really need to make this thing any more esoteric than it already is?  But, just when team BUILD thought the ceremony was going down in flames, the jury stepped in and provided a thought provoking, down-to-earth discussion and selected some projects that we are big fans of.  Enjoy…

UNBUILT / CONCEPTUAL PROJECTS

(2) CITATION AWARDS

Vo Shed by Atelier Jones
PP: The small shed which recycles vegetables brings about invention and delight
NT: Diminutive in scale it acts like a folly
SS: The jury was hoping for more of this type of work
vo-shed-by-atelier-jones-012

vo-shed-by-atelier-jones-02

Bumper Crop by The Miller Hull Partnership
DB: We take for granted that the suburban landscape can be transformed, this project is a re-colonization of the parking lot.
PP: This project isn’t conceptual enough
bumpercrop-by-miller-hull-01

bumpercrop-by-miller-hull-02

BUILT PROJECTS

(4) ACCOMMODATION AWARDS

Banner Gateway Medical Center by NBBJ
DB: The architecture speaks to how the patient is treated, it humanizes the experience
NT: The project reinvigorates the entire medical facility
PP: Breaking down the hospital into smaller chunks is better for the architecture and medical practice
bannergatewaymc-by-nbbj-01

bannergatewaymc-by-nbbj-02

The Terry Thomas by Weber Thompson Architects
NT: The ephemerality of the interior and quality of the space makes it a wonderful environment to be in.  Unfortunately the same level of sophistication was not matched on the outside of the building.
PP: The courtyard makes for a greater sense of community and the interior provides a value of the work environment.
DB: The systems were well integrated
the-terry-thomas-by-weber-thompson-011

the-terry-thomas-by-weber-thompson-02

56 Piles by E. Cobb Architects
PP: The project presents spatial organization as a future tool for architecture.  The overall composition rethinks the singular space.
56-piles-by-e-cobb-architects-01

56-piles-by-e-cobb-architects-02

Agnes Lofts by Weinstein A|U
NT: It’s rare to see a project like this with such a sense of reduction, the project is really about taking away, erasing.
DB: The building adopts key views and activates the ground.
agnes-lofts-by-weinstein-au-01

agnes-lofts-by-weinstein-au-02

(4) MERIT AWARDS

Kitsap County Administration Building by The Miller Hull Partnership
DB: It is rare to do something of this level in a city this small
PP: There were no plan drawings turned in with this entry – plans should always be included.
kitsap-county-admin-building-by-miller-hull-01

kitsap-county-admin-building-by-miller-hull-02

Envelope House by Bohlin Cywinski Jackson
NT: The problem of the site is engaging like a puzzle piece, while compact that project extrudes out bays and rooms
DB: The project is sustainable because of its density
envelope-house-by-bohlin-cywinski-jackson-01

envelope-house-by-bohlin-cywinski-jackson-02

Gym by E. Cobb Architects
PP: The spaces are nestled in intelligent ways.  The inventive compaction is offset by loose fabrication.  The space divides and also reinterprets the historic architecture.
gym-by-e-cobb-architects-01

gym-by-e-cobb-architects-02

Noah’s Ark by Olson Sundberg Kundig Allen
PP: Animals made out of recycled materials.
noahs-ark-by-oska-01

(4) HONOR AWARDS

EX3 Ron Sandwith Teen Center by Weinstein A|U
PP: The warehouse construction has a quality of ephemeral light.
ex3-by-weinstein-au-01

ex3-by-weinstein-au-02

Seattle Public Library Montlake Branch by Weinstein A|U
NT: There is a strong relationship between the whole and the parts, and between the inside and the outside.  The building doesn’t over scale the neighborhood.  The downspouts gotta go.
Weinstein AU- Montlake Library

montlake-library-by-weinstein-au-02

Woodway Residence by Bohlin Cywinski Jackson
DB: The project is a good example of sustainability by reusing a 1960’s case study house.
PP: A good exploration of possibilities and investment.
woodway-residence-by-bohlin-cywinski-jackson-01

woodway-residence-by-bohlin-cywinski-jackson-02

7 by Hutchinson & Maul
PP: The project is abstract but deeply embedded in place.
NT: There was something about the project that was unnamable.
7-by-hutchison-maul-01

7-by-hutchison-maul-02

In conclusion:
The jury mentioned that the notion of bottom up sustainable design is very relevant and that inventing new categories for sustainable design will be increasingly important.  All the 2008 honor award entries can be viewed here.

A huge thanks to the 2008 AIA Honor Awards Committee Members that must have worked their tails off to make all this happen.

Throw down a comment and let us know what you think…

Advertisements

10 Comments so far
Leave a comment

The Weinstein Loft project is really great- I’d think if they liked that project then the critics would have liked Park Modern, but I guess it wasn’t chosen from what I see here.

Comment by Samuel

I thought the awards were very sensibly awarded this year. Smart projects done with intelligence and mastery. However, out of the 14 awards I’d toss out OSKA’s Ark and Hutchison & Maul’s 7. These projects strike me as art rather than architecture. Shouldn’t there be some minimum level of performance in terms of keeping heat in and rain out?

Comment by Keyser

keyser,
i think it’s an attempt to say that our world (architect) encompasses both and that being able to navigate the two ( a la JM Cava & hutchison + maul) is a very positive thing.

minimum performance levels would also preclude some really interesting follies in recent years, such as VO Shed.

Comment by mike

Is it me or do the juries of these awards seem to be reluctantly rewarding the projects? There were an awful lot caveats placed on the awards. I am also a little disappointed that in the two most recent honor awards (Seattle AIA and Washington AIA), award was repeatedly given to the same firm(s). This tells me that the jury’s decisions are highly stylized and less critically cognizant of design solutions. Overall, NOT impressed.

Comment by jGo

There did seem to be some reluctance on behalf of the jurors in terms of actually awarding anything, however… this years awards ceremony was exteremely refreshing in that the same OSKA/Suyama type of precious little art galleries for wealthy clients weren’t being rewarded.

Comment by Anonymous

There was a greater sense of economy at this years awards – not just cost-effectiveness but intelligent use of land and built space. I’m hoping that this is a developing thesis for the awards rather than just a circumstance of which jurors happen to be selected.

Comment by buildllc

uh, yeah, and if you guys are hiring and want to do more public work, you have my email…

woot woot gobama!

Comment by mike

wow. good stuff happening over there!

Comment by Adam Crain

If you do not submit plans & jury does not visit building then you should not get an AIA award…period.

Comment by unknown arch

[…] Also read threads/comments at Archinect (posted by holz about 3/4 of the way down the thread), BLDG Blog and at AIA […]

Pingback by SeattleScape » Blog Archive » AIA Seattle winners and juror comments online




Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: